And 94 issues into the series, Sophia is still going strong. Before Frank Darabont found out the first season would only have six episodes, Shane was originally going to die in the first season. It was later decided that Shane would die at the end of the second season. We knew what we were doing there. We knew it would land a punch.
We do have internal rules for that. He is one of the few characters to have appeared in almost all forms of The Walking Dead media. Unlike his appearance in the comic books, Shane is in his mids, while the comic book Shane is The ending would have been the same up until the point when Shane and Rick walk into the clearing while searching for Randall.
Rick would have asked why they are stopping in the field as they need to find their prisoner, to which Shane would have confessed that he had killed Randall which is a job Rick should have done himself.
Shane then would have pulled his gun on Rick leading to similar dialogue between the two men as in the final episode, with the second change being that Shane would have admitted he was there to kill Rick. Carl would have then had shown up and killed zombified Shane, similarly again to the final episode. The comic book version of Monroe — a bald man named Douglas, instead of the sorghum-craving Deanna show-only viewers got to meet — also dies during the chaos at Alexandria, but in much less heroic fashion.
There, Monroe is eaten alive by walkers while he shoots his gun wildly. Clearly, the show took different approaches to killing both Denise and Abraham. There are exceptions to the rule, of course. Some deaths on the show played out exactly, or close to, the way they played out in the comics. For instance …. In the case of Glenn, we now know which side of the divide he stands on: as one of the few examples of someone whose fate on the show mirrors the same fate from the source material … well, almost.
Bookmark THR. Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day. Carl would definitely have been setting up a cat-and-mouse game, laying traps and ways to get Shane killed by walkers. This could have made him more ruthless and even resulted in a civil war with those who Shane saved and who felt no matter what, he was still a good leader. That personal approach would have been interesting as the monster in the camp, the wolf in sheep's clothing, has a different emotional ring to it than stumbling upon tyrants on the road like the Governor , Negan or the Whisperers.
This could have seen Carl triumph and slip into Rick's shoes thereafter, all the way up to the Commonwealth. It would have made him more battle-ready and who knows, maybe his mom would have lived, as well as his baby sister. The fact Carl lives until the end would also have made the Old Man Carl story so fitting as he'd have been the protagonist to have seen everyone unite and create a new, peaceful world. Plus, as a youngster, him finding romance with Lydia and building a relationship, thus connecting with a younger audience, especially as he'd have been torn with greater responsibilities as a leader.
It would have been more difficult on the TV show , though, as Andrew Lincoln was a darling since Episode 1. Rick killed Shane in the show so had he gone out this early, Shane would have been teaching Carl, making for some really uncomfortable moments. This might have eventually led to him killing Shane and Daryl possibly becoming the alpha in the pack, but what makes it so unlikely is Carl was too young to lead the show.
If it went that bold route, though, some adults who were killed off may have found themselves staying on longer like Andrea and Lori.
0コメント